How do you solve a problem like Edsa?

IN the early a part of his time period, President Rodrigo Duterte boasted that he might solve the Metro Manila visitors in three months. With solely a month remaining earlier than he steps down, Edsa—essentially the most congested highway artery in Metro Manila—stays to be simply that.

The normally horrific metro visitors state of affairs solely acquired a fleeting respite when Covid-19 lockdowns decongested Edsa of autos. As well being restrictions started easing as much as pave the way in which for the reopening of extra companies, visitors went again to “hellish normal” alongside this 23.8-kilometer circumferential highway.

Edsa or Epifanio de los Santos Avenue, identified within the Nineteen Fifties as Freeway 54, connects the northern and southern a part of the metro, in addition to South Luzon and North Luzon. Within the late Nineteen Eighties, after the 1986 Edsa Folks Energy Revolt, and thru the Nineties, building boomed within the metro. What was fulfilling journey alongside Edsa light, as malls, residential subdivisions, and workplace buildings started sprouting on large vacant heaps. Nightmarish visitors snarls notably grew to become rampant.

At first, many public officers held the myopic view that the burgeoning automobile congestion was a signal of progress. However as metro visitors more and more put a dent within the nation’s economic system and frayed the nerves of motorists and commuters alike, a number of schemes to decongest Edsa had been carried out, principally to no avail.

In line with a research completed by the Japan Worldwide Cooperation Company (JICA), the Philippines is in nice hazard of shedding P5.4 billion every day by 2035 if visitors congestion stays unchecked. JICA’s earlier estimate positioned the every day losses attributable to visitors congestion at P3.5 billion. The up to date document comes from JICA’s 2017  “Follow Up Survey on the Roadmap for Transport Infrastructure Development for Greater Capital Region.”

To be truthful, each administration has made the hassle to decongest Edsa. President Corazon Aquino’s transport secretary Oscar Orbos instituted the yellow-lane scheme, the place the 2 outermost lanes of four- to six-lane roads had been allotted for public utility autos, principally buses. Metropolitan Manila Growth Authority (MMDA) government director Col. Romeo Maganto throughout President Fidel Ramos’s time period developed in 1995 the quantity or shade coding system, initially concentrating on public utility autos and later increasing to all autos plying Edsa the place visitors congestion in Metro Manila was at its heaviest. Autos coated beneath the unique Unified Vehicular Quantity Discount Program had been banned from Edsa for the whole day primarily based on the final digit of a automobile’s license plate, much like the present UVVRP. Since then, nothing has appeared to work in the long run, sadly.

In 2019, Manila was dubbed essentially the most congested metropolis by each the Asian Growth Financial institution (ADB) and the TomTom Visitors Index. Now, the MMDA desires to debate with stakeholders two quantity coding schemes, which is able to ban autos from public roads throughout rush hours on two weekdays in a bid to cut back heavy visitors in Metro Manila.

MMDA Chairman Romando Artes stated the primary scheme goals to chop down visitors by 50 p.c. It should ban autos having registration plates with odd final numbers—1, 3, 5, 7, 9—on Monday and Thursday from 7:00 to 10:00 a.m. and from 5:00 to eight:00 p.m. Autos with registration plates ending in even numbers—2, 4, 6, 8, 0—might be banned from public roads on Tuesday and Friday throughout the identical hours. On Wednesdays, all autos might be allowed to make use of public roads. I’ll spare you the small print of the second scheme as a result of this proposal appears to simply rehash in a complicated means the mechanics of the primary scheme. Suffice it to say that this scheme goals to chop down visitors by 40 p.c. 

Artes stated that latest knowledge present that 60 to 70 p.c of the 300,000 autos bought within the nation in 2021 enter Metro Manila.  Visitors demand within the metro, reviews, is round 12.8 million journeys. Whereas 69 p.c of that’s made utilizing obtainable public transportation like jeepneys, buses, the LRT and the MRT, a considerably decrease portion is finished by driving or driving non-public autos. And but, the non-public mode of transport is claimed to occupy 78 p.c of highway area.

Why is there visitors congestion? When demand for a highway area turns into higher than what is accessible, visitors snarls happen. Individuals who stay removed from their office will take up highway area once they journey to and from Metro Manila, the place many firms are centered in a variety of places inside city settings, resembling Bonifacio World Metropolis, Ortigas CBD, Makati Enterprise Heart (Ayala), Rockwell Heart, Alabang, Pasay, and Triangle Park in Quezon Metropolis. In different components of the Philippines, the identical problem happens in Metro Davao and Metro Cebu.

Edsa and different metro roads, provides, are a good instance of “the tragedy of the commons” as a result of they’re free to make use of. Therefore, there’s little incentive for individuals who personal vehicles to not “use the hell out of it.”

Anthony Downs, an economist, says rush hour visitors congestion is unavoidable. “It is the direct consequence of having the standard work schedule that we all know too well.” When roads are handled like items in a capitalist nation that may be had both by paying a payment or on a first-come first-serviced coverage, Downs explains, visitors congestion turns into “akin to the latter.” Unhappy to say that on Edsa, rush hour is all-day-long, apart from possibly the wee hours of the morning.

Are highway widening and constructing auxiliary expressways the reply? In line with researchers from London College of Economics and College of Toronto, there exists a basic legislation of highway congestion: constructing and widening new roads may even trigger visitors density to stand up once more to earlier ranges. They decided the variety of vehicle-kilometers traveled and noticed a proportionate improve to the lane-kilometers obtainable on roads.

A number of administrations have proven how band-aid or short-term options do not work for the gargantuan and sophisticated problem that’s Edsa visitors. It’s true that reducing the quantity of autos crisscrossing Edsa’s asphalt floor every day is essential. Implementing number-coding schemes to cut back the variety of non-public autos utilizing it, banning provincial buses, and even making sections of Edsa one-way lanes, are usually not sufficient. Coding schemes will simply push wealthy motorists to purchase extra vehicles. The provincial bus ban has solely inspired extra colorum conveyances to take over. Making Edsa a one-way highway appears like an overreach that somebody with a hangover will need to have dreamed of. 

With the Duterte administration on its previous couple of weeks in energy, it has no extra time left to implement a viable and efficient visitors scheme to ease the hardship of motorists and commuters. The following administration should use its six-year time period to train its political will in bettering roads and highway community. We merely don’t have sufficient roads for autos, and it’s not getting any higher. Data present that in Metro Manila, the present ratio is at 1 km of highway for each 424 autos. In Cebu, highway expansions are costing the provincial authorities P1.1 billion in every day losses. Additionally city planning issues should be totally addressed. As an example, Metro Manila, Cebu, and even the comparatively smaller metropolis of Cagayan de Oro lacked foresight when it comes to city planning. The prevailing city format didn’t consider the sudden inhabitants progress particularly in areas that have transient populations, or those that don’t essentially stay there however work within the space on a every day foundation.

Most significantly, encouraging automotive riders to make use of public transportation should be a high precedence. In fact, this might be attainable if and solely when the general public might be supplied with a much-awaited and long-desired environment friendly, economical, and dependable mass transportation system.

For feedback and solutions, e-mail me at

Supply hyperlink

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.